Editorial
In Pakistan, successive governments have frequently resorted to data manipulation to present an image of better economic performance than what reality suggests. This trend points to the dominance of political interests over genuine economic concerns. One might argue that withholding or delaying the release of critical data does not necessarily mean the government is unaware of the prevailing issues. However, this approach raises significant concerns, especially when Pakistan is under the scrutiny of international bodies like the International Monetary Fund (IMF), with which it has had a long-standing relationship.
A prime example of data deferral is the delayed population census, which plays a crucial role in resource distribution and constituency demarcation. Similarly, the absence of recent data on household income, last collected in 2019, has hampered various administrations’ ability to assess domestic poverty levels. This is particularly critical when considering the massive decline in inflation, which fell from over 35% to just 4.1% in December 2024, but has not resulted in a noticeable improvement in the public’s economic well-being.
Pl watch the video and subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com
While official data on poverty may be scarce, alternative credible sources, such as international donor agencies and private economists, have provided alarming insights. The World Bank’s report predicts an increase in poverty to 25.3% by 2024, pushing millions deeper into hardship. Additionally, local think tanks and economists have highlighted discrepancies in government statistics, often facing pressure or threats for releasing their findings.
Despite these challenges, Pakistani administrations are not alone in their tendency to manipulate macroeconomic indicators, but such manipulation should be limited to analysis and not extend to the data itself. The IMF’s recent report emphasized the need for improving the quality and granularity of Pakistan’s economic data, particularly regarding GDP calculations and government finance statistics.
To address these issues, it is vital for Pakistan’s government to prioritize poverty data collection, which will provide a clearer understanding of the public’s economic struggles and allow for more effective policy responses. As the country enters 2025, a shift in focus from elite-driven resource allocation to poverty reduction could help regain public trust and stabilize the economy.
