Dr Riaz Cheema

Introduction:

The concept of reforms in the Pakistani context has evolved over time in response to the challenges faced by the education sector and the broader socio-economic environment. Reforms are typically viewed as necessary interventions aimed at improving the effectiveness, accessibility, and quality of various systems, particularly in education. In Pakistan, education reforms have focused on addressing systemic issues such as low literacy rates, gender disparities, inadequate infrastructure, poor governance, and limited access to quality education. However, the process of reform is complex, often subject to political and social influences, and fraught with challenges.

In Pakistan, education reforms are often driven by political agendas, and their implementation tends to be episodic rather than continuous. The education sector has been subject to frequent shifts in policy, particularly with changes in political leadership. This means that reforms introduced by one government are often abandoned by the next, leading to a lack of continuity and long-term vision in the education system. As a result, many educational initiatives have been sporadic, fragmented, and insufficiently resourced. The country’s political instability, changing leadership, and lack of political will have hindered the establishment of a consistent education policy.

For example, the introduction of the National Education Policy 2009 promised significant improvements in education, such as increasing the budget allocation for education to 6% of GDP. However, this commitment has not been fully realized, and despite the framework, Pakistan continues to face numerous challenges in achieving the objectives set out in the policy.

A central theme of education reforms in Pakistan has been the achievement of Universal Primary Education (UPE). This goal is closely linked to the global education agenda, particularly the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and later the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). While significant strides have been made in increasing enrollment rates at the primary school level, Pakistan still faces challenges in ensuring that all children—especially those from rural, marginalized, or impoverished backgrounds—have access to education. Social factors, including poverty, child labor, and early marriage, continue to keep many children out of school, especially girls.

Furthermore, the quality of education in primary schools remains a concern, with large class sizes, poorly trained teachers, outdated curricula, and inadequate learning materials limiting the educational experience. In rural areas, the lack of basic facilities such as electricity, clean water, and sanitation in schools exacerbates the problem, contributing to high dropout rates and low retention.

One of the key goals of education reforms has been to address the gender gap in education. Pakistan has made some progress in terms of increasing the enrollment of girls in schools, but disparities persist. According to various reports, gender parity is still a significant issue in rural areas, where cultural and social norms often restrict girls’ access to education. The reform agenda has included targeted interventions to improve girls’ education, such as offering scholarships, increasing the number of female teachers, and building separate girls’ schools in remote areas. However, these efforts remain insufficient given the cultural resistance to girls’ education in certain parts of the country.

Moreover, inequities between urban and rural education systems persist. Urban areas often have better access to resources, qualified teachers, and modern infrastructure, while rural areas suffer from inadequate facilities and low-quality education. Addressing these disparities is a key part of the reform process, but challenges remain in ensuring that all students, regardless of gender or geographical location, have access to quality education.

The concept of adult literacy is also central to the education reform agenda in Pakistan. The country faces a significant adult illiteracy problem, particularly among women and older generations. Adult literacy programs, which combine functional literacy with vocational skills, have been implemented in various regions, particularly in rural areas. These programs have had some success, with a reduction in dropout rates among participants and a positive impact on their ability to contribute to the local economy.

However, adult literacy programs remain limited in scope and are often underfunded. There is a need for a more systematic and large-scale approach to adult education, incorporating vocational training and skill development to empower the adult population, particularly women, and equip them with skills that are marketable in a modern economy.

One of the most critical elements of education reform in Pakistan is improving the quality of teaching. Teachers’ lack of training and professional development has been a long-standing issue. In many parts of Pakistan, teachers are inadequately trained, and there is a lack of accountability for their performance. The quality of teaching is further compromised by low salaries, poor working conditions, and limited opportunities for professional development.

Reforms in this area have included initiatives to improve teacher training programs, both pre-service and in-service, and to provide continuous professional development opportunities. However, these efforts have not been scaled up sufficiently to meet the demand for qualified educators. A concerted effort is needed to improve teacher quality through more rigorous recruitment standards, better training, and ongoing professional development.

Educational infrastructure in Pakistan is severely lacking, particularly in rural and underserved areas. Many schools lack basic facilities such as proper classrooms, sanitation, libraries, and access to information technology. The lack of infrastructure often undermines the efforts to provide quality education. Education reforms need to prioritize the improvement of school infrastructure to create a conducive learning environment.

Resource allocation remains a critical issue as well. The education budget in Pakistan has historically been insufficient to meet the demands of the sector. The allocation has often been below 2% of GDP, which is far from the 6% target recommended in national education policies. The inadequate budgetary provisions contribute to poor maintenance, low utilization of resources, and the failure to implement critical reforms.

Education reforms in Pakistan have often been hampered by poor governance and weak accountability structures. Corruption, political interference, and a lack of transparency have undermined the effectiveness of reforms. A key aspect of the reform agenda should be the strengthening of governance structures at all levels—federal, provincial, and local. This includes improving transparency in the allocation and use of funds, ensuring the effective monitoring and evaluation of educational programs, and enhancing the role of communities in managing schools.

Decentralization has been proposed as a way to improve governance in the education sector. By empowering local communities, schools, and education officials, Pakistan can increase accountability and improve the quality of education. However, effective decentralization requires the building of local capacities, better communication, and the establishment of strong local education authorities.

The concept of education reforms in Pakistan is complex and multifaceted, involving political, social, and economic dimensions. While significant efforts have been made to improve access to education, the country continues to face enormous challenges related to quality, equity, governance, and resource allocation. Reforms need to be continuous, apolitical, and backed by strong political will and adequate funding. To achieve meaningful change, Pakistan must commit to long-term, sustained reforms that focus on improving teacher quality, infrastructure, and inclusivity, while addressing the deep-rooted socio-cultural barriers to education, particularly for women and marginalized communities. Only then can the country begin to realize the full potential of its education system and contribute to the broader goals of national development and poverty reduction.

Discussion:

Pakistan’s education system has undergone numerous structural and cosmetic reforms since the newly established state inherited an education system inherited from its colonial past. The country faced the challenge of adapting and transforming this inherited system to fit its newly independent status. This article critically evaluates the successive educational reforms, examining how far these reforms have succeeded in creating a modern teaching-learning environment suited to Pakistan’s academic and socio-economic needs. The study takes a chronological approach to explore the influence of political motives, ideological agendas, and the vested interests of various regimes on the development of the education system. The analysis is based on qualitative observations, including over a decade of experience in educational policy and planning.

The article highlights that many of these reforms were largely driven by political objectives rather than genuine educational aims. They failed to focus on delivering meaningful, practical education that would meet the evolving socio-economic needs of the country. The reforms did not prioritize modern educational practices, internationally accepted teaching standards, or a coherent approach to curriculum development. Issues such as infrastructure, resource allocation, and alignment with technological advancements were frequently neglected. The article suggests that fundamental and realistic steps are required to bridge the gap between the existing educational framework and modern pedagogical needs, keeping in mind Pakistan’s unique cultural and economic context.

Education plays a central role in the development of a nation, shaping human capital, fostering innovation, and driving economic progress. As such, educational reforms should not be seen as a one-off process but as an ongoing effort to adapt to the ever-expanding frontiers of knowledge. This article seeks to provide an overview of the educational policies and reforms over the past two centuries, analyzing how governmental interests, political ideologies, and regime involvement have influenced the educational landscape of Pakistan. Quantitative analysis, while important, cannot fully capture the complexities of education, which involve social, psychological, ideological, and motivational dimensions. Therefore, this study adopts a historical lens, recognizing the state’s role in shaping the intellectual and creative potential of its citizens through organized, institutionalized knowledge transfer. The paper delves into various elements of educational reforms, including curriculum design, teaching methods, teacher training, and the provision of physical infrastructure, with a focus on assessing the political will behind these changes and their impact on the overall effectiveness of the reforms.

The politics of education reform in Pakistan have been deeply entwined with the country’s political economy, with various regimes using education policies as tools to further their political agendas. Education reforms have often been reactive, shaped by political exigencies rather than a coherent vision for the long-term development of the education system. The lack of political will and the constant shifts in educational policies have hindered the progress of the education sector, with reforms often being inconsistent or implemented ineffectively. A critical evaluation of education policies from both pre-and post-independence eras reveals a clear pattern of political manipulation of education for ideological and strategic purposes rather than genuine concern for the welfare of students and the broader society.

Pre-independence education policies in British India set the stage for Pakistan’s education system, as the colonial government introduced reforms that were primarily designed to serve its own interests. The British education system focused on creating a class of educated Indians who would serve the colonial administration, rather than fostering broader intellectual and technical development. Key reforms like the Charter Act of 1813 and the Macaulay Minutes of 1835 promoted English language education and neglected indigenous languages, sciences, and local history. The British education system was designed to serve the empire, and its limited focus on literacy, mass education, and technical training left a deep disconnect between the needs of Indian society and the education system. This legacy shaped the early years of Pakistan’s educational reforms, with the newly independent state inheriting a system that was ill-suited to its needs.

After independence, Pakistan introduced several educational reforms aimed at promoting ideological goals, such as the role of Islam in public life, as well as practical concerns like technical and vocational education. However, these reforms were often influenced by political imperatives, and the country’s education policies remained deeply inconsistent. From the early educational conferences to the National Education Policies introduced by various governments, Pakistan’s education reforms have been driven by political motivations, ranging from the emphasis on character-building and ideological education to the desire for mass literacy and vocational training. While there have been efforts to expand access to education and integrate the private sector, these initiatives were often marred by a lack of political stability, inadequate funding, and poor implementation.

For instance, Pakistan’s first educational conference in 1947 set the foundation for education reforms but failed to allocate sufficient resources, leading to stalled progress in the following years. Successive military regimes, such as those led by General Ayub Khan and General Zia-ul-Haq, implemented their own education policies that reflected their political agendas. These policies often focused on ideological education, including the Islamization of the curriculum under Zia, which was criticized for its contradictions and inefficiencies. Similarly, the nationalization of private educational institutions in the 1970s had a significant impact on the private sector’s contribution to quality education, and its reversal in the 1980s further destabilized the sector.

Despite these challenges, more recent policies, such as the National Education Policy of 2009, have attempted to address some of the systemic issues by emphasizing universal primary education, vocational training, and quality assurance. However, these policies too have struggled to deliver on their promises due to political upheavals, lack of resources, and inconsistent implementation. The lack of a cohesive and long-term strategy for educational reform continues to be a significant barrier to Pakistan’s educational development.

Finally, Pakistan’s education system has undergone numerous reforms, but these reforms have often been driven by political motives rather than the genuine need for a transformative, knowledge-based education system. To achieve meaningful progress, the country must prioritize the development of a modern, inclusive, and sustainable education system that meets the socio-economic needs of the population and aligns with international standards. The focus should be on providing quality education that equips students with the skills necessary for the demands of a rapidly changing global economy. This will require not only political will but also a comprehensive and consistent approach to educational planning, resource allocation, and curriculum development that takes into account Pakistan’s unique cultural and economic challenges.

Political Education System:

The politics surrounding educational reforms in Pakistan is intricately linked to a complex, multi-tiered education system that serves to perpetuate significant inequality. The education system in the country consists of various sectors, including elite private schools, public-sector institutions, and specialized public schools like Divisional Public Schools and Danish Schools. This system has created a stark divide between the rich and the poor, with access to quality education being largely restricted to a small, privileged group, including urban elites, bureaucrats, and the landed aristocracy. The majority of the population, however, struggles with issues such as lack of access, poor quality of education, and inadequate facilities.

This systemic inequity is compounded by political and governance challenges. Despite the 18th Amendment to the Constitution and the inclusion of Article 25-A, which recognizes the right to education up to the secondary level, meaningful change has been slow, and the educational landscape in Pakistan remains largely unchanged. Key issues such as governance failures, low enrollment rates, teacher absenteeism, and inadequate resources continue to plague the sector. These persistent challenges demand urgent, comprehensive reforms that focus on access, equity, and the improvement of educational outcomes.

The historical failure of education reforms in Pakistan can be attributed to a combination of political instability, lack of continuity, and inadequate resource allocation. Reforms have often been driven by political motives rather than a genuine desire to improve the education sector. Education reforms, which should ideally address fundamental issues such as access, equity, and quality, have instead been inconsistent, with successive governments introducing new policies without substantial follow-through. The outcome of these reforms has been limited, with enrollment rates stagnating and dropout rates remaining high. For example, over 6 million children remain out of school, and illiteracy continues to affect over 50 million people in the country. Despite the introduction of various national education policies, including the 2009 National Education Policy and the 2018 National Education Policy Framework, progress has been slow. The lack of a clear, consistent strategy for reform implementation, combined with the absence of a robust monitoring system, has resulted in stagnation. Moreover, the underfunding of education, with allocations often falling below 2% of GDP, highlights the lack of political will to address the sector’s needs.

In the new millennium, the challenge of reforming Pakistan’s education system requires a comprehensive and sustainable approach.

First, the country must develop a cohesive policy framework that ensures equity in education, aligning with national and international goals such as the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and Education for All (EFA) targets. Pakistan must address the significant gaps in its education system, particularly in terms of quality and access. There is also a pressing need for reforms that focus on the professional development of teachers, the improvement of governance structures, and the provision of basic facilities in schools. To ensure long-term success, education reforms must be aligned with the constitutional rights outlined in Article 25-A, guaranteeing the right to education for all children. For this to happen, substantial investments in the education sector are necessary, with an increase in the allocation of national resources, a commitment to equitable resource distribution, and a clear implementation strategy that involves all stakeholders, including provincial governments, civil society, and private sector partners.

Pl watch the video and subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com

Pakistan’s education system also needs to adapt to the changing demands of the global economy, particularly in terms of skills development. There is a critical need to align the educational curriculum with emerging market demands and to foster stronger links between higher education institutions and the private sector. One potential solution is to expand the role of information technology in education, leveraging digital tools and platforms to improve both access and quality. The use of online learning, Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs), and digital resources can help bridge the gap between urban and rural educational opportunities. Furthermore, public-private partnerships (PPPs) can play a pivotal role in enhancing the quality of education. Successful models, such as the Punjab Education Foundation, have demonstrated the potential of such partnerships to improve learning outcomes, reduce dropout rates, and ensure teacher accountability.

Despite the challenges, there is reason for cautious optimism. The political resolve to prioritize education has been reaffirmed at the highest levels, particularly following the 18th Amendment and the joint declaration by the federal and provincial governments in 2011. These efforts, combined with an increased focus on education in the political agenda, represent a step in the right direction. However, the lack of concrete action, particularly in terms of resource allocation and policy continuity, remains a significant barrier to achieving meaningful change. For Pakistan to meet its educational goals and address the critical challenges of the sector, the government must prioritize education reform with a clear and consistent vision, backed by adequate funding, institutional capacity, and political commitment. The success of these reforms hinges on strong leadership, accountability, and a comprehensive approach that involves all sectors of society. Without such efforts, the promise of education as a tool for empowerment and national development will remain unfulfilled.

Conclusion:

The strategic priorities of Pakistan’s government through education reforms have traditionally aimed at achieving Universal Primary Education (UPE), improving access, quality, equity, and governance, while aligning with the broader Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). These goals included eradicating extreme poverty, improving access to education, reducing child mortality, combating disease, and fostering global development partnerships. Recent statistics, however, reveal that Pakistan is in serious jeopardy of missing the MDG targets, especially in areas like adult literacy and education access. While gender parity has been partially achieved, other essential goals, such as reducing illiteracy rates and improving education quality, still require substantial effort and political commitment. However, the intervention level thus far has been insufficient given the scale of the challenges facing the education sector. Addressing the issue of adult illiteracy requires a more comprehensive approach, combining functional literacy with vocational skills. Some successful adult literacy programs have already shown promising results, demonstrating the benefits of integrating literacy and vocational training. Scaling up these initiatives could make a significant impact on reducing illiteracy rates, particularly among marginalized adult populations.

A significant barrier to the success of education reforms in Pakistan is the weak planning and implementation mechanisms that have characterized past efforts. Commonly cited issues include inadequate financial resources, delays in budget allocations, poor maintenance of educational infrastructure, low utilization of funds, lack of trained personnel, and weak governance structures. These challenges are exacerbated by the absence of effective monitoring and evaluation mechanisms, as well as a lack of engagement with local communities in designing education policies. Without addressing these systemic deficiencies, efforts to reform the education system are unlikely to succeed. For reforms to be effective, they must be backed by strong political will, robust management practices, and a commitment to long-term consistency. Education reform cannot be subject to political whims, as changes in government often lead to the abandonment of previous initiatives. In many cases, these abandoned programs have become liabilities, with policymakers facing the challenge of addressing incomplete projects. To improve the education system, Pakistan must focus on enhancing teacher and manager capacity, implementing continuous assessment systems, providing quality textbooks, establishing information technology and science labs, and ensuring libraries in schools. Additionally, upgrading schools from primary to elementary levels and from elementary to high school levels, while addressing missing facilities, are critical steps toward meeting educational policy goals.

For education reforms to be successful, they must follow a consistent and ongoing process, supported by continuous monitoring, evaluation, and realignment. Reforms should not be politicized, as education plays a crucial role in nation-building and sustainable development. Therefore, the reformation process needs to be driven by clear goals and the commitment of all political parties to implement these changes. One of the most pressing needs in the education sector is the increased allocation of national resources, with the government targeting an increase in the education budget to at least 6% of GDP, as suggested in the National Education Policy 2009. Meeting this target would significantly bolster the government’s ability to implement Article 25-A of the Constitution, which guarantees the right to education. The importance of investing in education cannot be overstated, as the education system is fundamentally linked to economic growth and the overall development of the country. Policymakers must treat the successful implementation of education reforms as a top priority to ensure that Pakistan’s youth are equipped with the knowledge and skills needed to contribute to the nation’s future prosperity.

Local and International Standards for Reforming Education in Pakistan:

1. Curriculum Relevance and Quality:
   • Local: The curriculum should be updated regularly to reflect local cultural, historical, and economic realities, while ensuring that it prepares students for the modern workforce. The focus should be on critical thinking, problem-solving, and vocational skills that meet the needs of local industries.
   • International: The curriculum should align with global standards, particularly those of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). International benchmarks should be adopted for literacy, numeracy, and technical skills to prepare students for the global economy.
2. Equity and Access:
   • Local: Policymakers should work toward eliminating regional and gender disparities in education by prioritizing underserved areas. Special programs for girls’ education, rural education, and education for children with disabilities should be part of the national strategy.
   • International: Pakistan should adhere to the SDG Target 4.1, which calls for universal free and equitable primary and secondary education. Access to education for marginalized groups, such as ethnic minorities and those in remote areas, should be guaranteed, with a focus on inclusive education practices.
3. Teacher Training and Professional Development:
   • Local: In-service and pre-service teacher training programs should be standardized across provinces. Professional development initiatives must include the integration of technology in classrooms and focus on pedagogical skills.
   • International: Teachers should be trained according to international teaching standards, such as those set by the International Task Force on Teachers for Education 2030. These standards focus on improving teacher qualifications, supporting continuous professional development, and fostering inclusive teaching practices.
4. Governance and Accountability:
   • Local: Strengthening governance structures at the federal, provincial, and local levels is critical to the successful implementation of education reforms. School management committees, parent-teacher associations, and local education authorities should be empowered to improve school accountability and oversight.
   • International: Transparent governance structures must align with the principles set out in the Education for All (EFA) goals. Accountability measures should include regular audits, teacher evaluations, and clear reporting mechanisms to ensure that resources are used effectively and educational outcomes are achieved.
5. Use of Technology:
   • Local: The use of technology should be integrated into the classroom, focusing on both the training of teachers and the learning experiences of students. The government should invest in IT infrastructure, such as computer labs, digital content, and internet access, especially in rural areas.
   • International: Pakistan should adopt global best practices in educational technology, such as the use of Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs), digital classrooms, and blended learning models. The aim should be to use technology to bridge the gap between urban and rural educational opportunities, improve learning outcomes, and enhance access to quality educational resources.
6. Budget Allocation and Funding:
   • Local: Adequate funding for education reforms is essential. The government should increase the education budget to at least 6% of GDP, as outlined in national policy documents, and ensure that funds are allocated efficiently across provinces.
   • International: Pakistan should aim to meet international funding standards, as recommended by the Global Partnership for Education (GPE), which advocates for increased domestic funding for education and the efficient use of external aid. Transparent budget processes, along with rigorous monitoring and evaluation mechanisms, should be implemented to ensure that resources are used effectively.
7. Monitoring and Evaluation:
   • Local: There should be a strong national and provincial framework for monitoring and evaluating educational outcomes. Data collection systems should be strengthened to track progress on key indicators such as enrollment rates, literacy rates, and learning outcomes.
   • International: The monitoring and evaluation framework should align with global standards, such as those set by UNESCO’s Education Monitoring Report and the SDGs. Regular assessments should be conducted to ensure that education reforms are achieving their intended outcomes, with a focus on improving educational quality, access, and equity.

Hence, the education reforms in Pakistan need to be guided by a clear vision, political commitment, and the application of both local and international standards to ensure that education becomes a catalyst for national development. Only through sustained efforts, adequate funding, and effective governance can Pakistan hope to address the deep-rooted challenges in its education sector and meet its obligations under both national and international frameworks.