Dr Bilawal Kamran
The political atmosphere in South Asia is tense and fragile. It is filled with suspicion, mistrust, and quick reactions. In such a sensitive environment, every word matters because every statement carries weight. Leaders who hold state authority must speak with care. They must avoid words that ignite anger or deepen the divide. Sadly, this is not happening. Many Indian leaders continue to make statements that not only provoke Pakistan but also harm the entire region. Their tone is combative and their messaging is confrontational. This behaviour strengthens polarisation instead of peace. It creates fear and hostility on both sides. It also closes whatever small windows remain for dialogue. The need for responsible language is urgent because irresponsible language has consequences. It is time to recognise that rhetoric can damage stability in a region already suffering from political anxiety and economic struggle.
<a href=”http://republicpolicy.com” target=”_blank”>Republic Policy Website</a>
The recent remarks by Indian Defence Minister Rajnath Singh reflect this dangerous trend. Speaking at an event in Delhi, he stated that Sindh is no longer part of India but civilisationally Sindh will always belong to India. He further added that Sindh could one day return to India. These are not casual remarks. They are not harmless opinions. They are political statements by a senior minister of a nuclear state. They express a mindset that places mythology above international law. They also expose the influence of extremist ideological groups over Indian policymaking. Such language inflames emotions in Pakistan. It also reinforces the belief that certain factions within India are unwilling to accept the borders established in 1947. These remarks damage every possibility of peace. They send a message that India sees neighbouring territories not as sovereign lands but as cultural extensions of itself. This attitude fuels insecurity across the region.
<a href=”https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uL3-dG9koD4&t=229s&ab_channel=RepublicPolicy” target=”_blank”>Republic Policy YouTube</a>
The idea behind these remarks is rooted in the concept of Akhand Bharat. It is a political and ideological dream promoted by the Sangh Parivar. It imagines an ancient civilisation stretching from Afghanistan to Myanmar. It is not based on modern realities. It is not aligned with international norms. It is a fantasy that ignores the ground facts of history, geography, and sovereignty. When senior ministers echo these ideas, they blur the line between myth and state policy. This is dangerous because it creates expectations among their supporters. It also sends threatening signals to neighbouring nations. The concept of Akhand Bharat is not just unrealistic. It is destabilising. It undermines regional peace. It imposes insecurity on South Asian citizens. No responsible leadership should use such ideological tools for political advantage. Peace requires acceptance of borders. Peace requires respect, restraint, and maturity. These qualities seem to be missing in this discourse.
<a href=”https://twitter.com/RepublicPolicy” target=”_blank”>Republic Policy Twitter</a>
Pakistan has reacted firmly and responsibly to these remarks. The Foreign Office has called them delusional. This response is grounded in international law and historical truth. Sindh is a constitutional part of the sovereign state of Pakistan. Its people, its institutions, and its history are tied deeply with the journey of Pakistan. The Sindh Assembly expressed this clearly in a joint resolution. The National Assembly supported the same position. These reactions show unity within Pakistan. They show political clarity. They also show that Pakistan does not take territorial remarks lightly. Such statements from India are not viewed as academic debate. They are seen as potential threats to national security. Therefore, Pakistan’s response is dignified and firm. It is a reminder that sovereignty is non-negotiable. It is a reminder that national borders are protected through law, diplomacy, and collective consciousness.
<a href=”https://facebook.com/RepublicPolicy” target=”_blank”>Republic Policy Facebook</a>
Sindh has a long and rich history. It has existed for thousands of years. It carries the legacy of the Indus Valley. It holds traditions that shaped South Asian civilisation. The province is a mosaic of cultures, languages, and communities. It played a central role in the Pakistan Movement. Its people voted for the creation of Pakistan. Its leaders shaped national politics. Its cities contributed to intellectual, economic, and political life. Celebrating this heritage is important for cultural understanding. But this celebration must not be turned into a justification for territorial claims. Shared culture does not erase sovereign borders. Shared civilisation does not weaken national identity. India must understand that respect for sovereignty is the foundation of peace. Without this respect, history becomes a weapon. Culture becomes a tool for aggression. That is not acceptable in a modern world.
<a href=”https://tiktok.com/@republic_policy” target=”_blank”>Republic Policy TikTok</a>
The need now is for mature leadership across South Asia. Leaders must reduce tension, not increase it. They must promote cooperation, not confrontation. South Asia is home to nearly two billion people. These people need food, jobs, health care, and security. They need stable borders and peaceful governments. They do not need ideological wars. They do not need claims over lands that are not theirs. They do not need symbolic aggression that disrupts peace. Responsible leadership understands this. Responsible leadership speaks with discipline. It avoids statements that weaken trust. It encourages diplomacy. It encourages trade, connectivity, and regional development. South Asia cannot progress with hostile narratives. It can only progress through mutual respect and cooperation.
<a href=”https://instagram.com/republicpolicy” target=”_blank”>Republic Policy Instagram</a>
The future of South Asia depends on realism. It depends on accepting the present world, not the imagined world of ancient empires. Borders today are recognised through international law. They cannot be reshaped through emotional speeches. India must understand this. Pakistan understands this. Other South Asian countries understand this. Peace is possible only when each state respects the sovereignty of the other. It is also possible only when leaders speak responsibly. The region cannot afford rhetorical fire. It needs calm voices. It needs honest engagement. It needs courage to move beyond propaganda. South Asia has suffered for decades. It is time to prioritise development and human welfare. It is time to build trust, not break it. It is time to leave behind fantasies and walk toward cooperation. Only then can this region find the peace it deserves.
<a href=”https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaYMzpX5Ui2WAdHrSg1G” target=”_blank”>Republic Policy WhatsApp Channel</a>
