Federal Units versus Administrative Units

[post-views]

Tariq Mahmood Awan (Translated from Urdu)

It is essential to understand and clearly distinguish between Federal Units and Administrative Units. In a federation, provinces are federal units, not merely administrative units. These two concepts have distinct constitutional, political and administrative identities and cannot be used interchangeably.

I have also observed that even the creation of new tehsils and districts within a federal unit can be an extremely difficult process. Sometimes, it takes years to establish them, while several proposals fail to materialise altogether. Punjab is a clear example. Even when the demand for a new district arises from the basic needs and aspirations of the local population, translating it into reality often involves extraordinary difficulties.

If creating administrative districts and tehsils within a federal unit is so challenging, one can imagine how complicated it would be to redraw the boundaries of federal units or create new provinces in the country. Unfortunately, we have yet to fully understand the fundamental distinction between a federal unit and an administrative unit. Provinces are not merely administrative units; they are the constitutional, political and geographical units of a federation. Their creation, division or redrawing of boundaries cannot be undertaken merely to address administrative requirements.

Drawing new boundaries, altering the administrative map or restructuring provinces in a federal state is an exceptionally sensitive matter. A federal state has its own structure, requirements and sensitivities, whereas the administrative framework of a unitary state is fundamentally different. These two systems cannot be assessed by applying the same standards. Therefore, seeking solutions to administrative problems through the restructuring of federal units is not only inappropriate but also raises concerns about the stability of the federation.

In my book, Beyond the Four Provinces, I have discussed this fundamental distinction in detail, along with the concepts of federal units, administrative units and local governments. My position is that the way forward for transferring administrative authority to the grassroots and developing a more effective administrative structure does not lie in dividing provinces. Instead, it lies in establishing effective administrative units and empowered local governments.

Editorial notes: The author has written Pakistan’s first governance model, including five books. Get your copies including the best-selling book, The Bureaucratic Coup, from 0341-4222501 (WhatsApp)

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Videos
[youtube-feed feed=2]