Tariq Mahmood Awan

A multifaceted strategy is required to revamp Pakistan’s economy. Most importantly, the economy’s foundational pillars need reformation and restructuring to meet modern demands for competitiveness. First, the sectors of the economy need to be reformated, followed by simple and effective legal regimes. Structural, administrative, and financial reforms are also critical. The approach to reform the economy is progressive rather than regressive. Growth, manufacturing, services, and knowledge economy require legislative, legal, administrative, operational, and technological measures.  

The financial world uses economic sectors to categorize businesses based on their activities. These sectors provide a framework for understanding how different parts of the economy work together.

Imagine the economy as a giant machine with many moving parts. Sectors are like the different sections of this machine, each responsible for a specific task. A sector groups businesses that share similar activities, products, or services. This grouping helps economists analyze economic activity, and investors make informed decisions.

There are typically four main economic sectors:

• Primary Sector: This sector extracts raw materials directly from nature. It includes businesses involved in mining, fishing, agriculture, and forestry. Think of it as the foundation of the economic machine, providing the basic building blocks for other sectors.
• Secondary Sector: Here, businesses take the raw materials from the primary sector and transform them into finished goods. Manufacturing, construction, and processing facilities fall under this category. They take the iron ore from mines and turn it into cars, the wood from forests and turn it into furniture, and so on.
• Tertiary Sector: This is the largest sector in most developed economies. It encompasses businesses that provide services to consumers and other businesses. Examples include retailers, restaurants, financial institutions, healthcare providers, and transportation companies. The tertiary sector takes care of our daily needs and keeps the economic machine running smoothly.
• Quaternary Sector: This is a relatively new sector that emerged with the rise of the knowledge-based economy. It focuses on intellectual activities like information technology, research and development, education, and consulting services. The quaternary sector helps us innovate and improve processes, leading to advancements across the entire economic machine.

Sectors play a crucial role in understanding how the economy is performing. A surge in demand for raw materials like copper or crude oil might signal economic expansion as businesses ramp up production. Analyzing how different sectors perform can reveal the economy’s strengths and weaknesses. For instance, strong growth in the manufacturing sector (secondary) could indicate a healthy economy.

Investors use sectors to group stocks and assess potential risks and rewards. Sectors that benefit from economic growth, like technology or real estate, might attract more investment during prosperous times.

While sectors represent broad categories, industries are even more specific groupings within a sector. For example, the energy sector might have sub-industries like oil and gas or renewable energy. Companies, organizations, and businesses within the same industry directly compete with each other.

Understanding the differences between sectors and industries helps gain a more granular view of the economic landscape. Sectors are a powerful tool for comprehending how the economy functions. By analyzing different sectors, we can assess financial health, make informed investment decisions, and track the evolution of various industries. Therefore, it is essential to categorize the economy into sectors and develop each sector for a functional economy. However, different nations are blessed with different primary sectors. Therefore, it is essential to construct secondary sectors accordingly. Developing the tertiary and quaternary sectors by developing human resource management standards is even more critical. 

Pakistan possesses immense economic potential, but unlocking it requires a concerted effort on multiple fronts. Primarily, all four sectors of the economy must be restricted. So far, our economy depends upon the sub-sectors of the primary sector. Agriculture and other natural resources need more productivity, growth, and operational methods. Unfortunately, the sub-sectors of the secondary sector are not operationally competitive. Likewise, the tertiary sector needs investment and operative human resource management. The tertiary sector is vital for Pakistan’s economy. The world has developed into a knowledge economy. However, our scientific and human resource standards must match the competition. The sectors of the economy will only grow if primary principles are ensured in Pakistan’s governance system, which is critical for the economy’s growth. 

Political stability is vital for economic growth to thrive in a stable environment. A government with broad public support fosters confidence among citizens and businesses. Transparent elections, accountable leadership, and a commitment to democratic principles pave the way for long-term planning and consistent policies that attract investment. Therefore, the government must represent the will of the people. A representative government will only legislate and implement the legislative policies according to the economic interest of the public rather than the elite in Pakistan. A representative government can only initiate the process of economic reforms and restructuring.  

The government’s role is only regulatory and facilitation. The current generalist bureaucracy often needs specialized knowledge to manage complex sectors effectively. Shifting to a system where bureaucrats cum professionals possess expertise in specific areas, such as planning, development, health, agriculture, or finance, can lead to more informed decision-making, similar to the French model. The specialization of bureaucracy is vital for delivering economic deliverables such as implementing and managing governmental institutions directly related to the economy’s growth. A functionally specialized bureaucracy will only develop standards and assurances in sub-sectors for food, energy, and human resources.  

Administrative processes bogged down by red tape can stifle progress. Reforming the system to streamline procedures, enhance service delivery, and improve accountability at all levels is crucial. Modernizing administrative structures and systems will promote efficiency and responsiveness. We run an NOC economy where excessive documentation can lead to investor disinterest. There is a dire need to simplify the rules, procedures, and documentation so business people, investors, and others may develop confidence in the administration system. Efficient public sector administrative reforms are vital. Accordingly, the Planning Commission, Provincial Planning and Development Departments, Finance, Agriculture, Industry, Commerce and Trade, and all those departments catering to the four sectors of the economy must be revamped for productivity and growth.  

A functional governance system is vital for revamping the economy. The devolution is instrumental in developing the local and domestic economy. Likewise, devolving power to local governments allows communities to address their specific needs efficiently. Functional local governments empower citizens, encourage grassroots development, and ensure better representation. Learning from successful models in other countries can provide valuable insights into Pakistan’s approach. A functional local government system is vital for the domestic economy, catering to the primary sector of the economy, which is as important as the secondary or international economy. Governments must refrain from running businesses and facilitate the private sector to grow and manufacture goods and services. Therefore, the government should devolve power to all tiers of government so that they can engage local and national business people, farmers, service providers, and specialists to develop and accordingly play their role in the revival and development of the Pakistani economy.

The most problematic issue is the complex and outdated economic law regimes. Complex and obsolete economic laws hinder business development. Streamlining and simplifying tax codes, regulations, and legal frameworks will encourage investment and business activities. Transparency and consistent law application are essential for building trust among businesses. Fiscal, monetary, economic, taxation, and development laws should be simple, efficient, and progressive. Suppose federal and provincial governments can ensure functional legislation, delegated legislation, and formulation of executive laws in all sectors of the economy. In that case, the economy might be revamped through short-medium and long-term plans and strategies. Hence, consistency and longevity of the laws are paramount.  

While foreign direct investment (FDI) can be beneficial, promoting local direct investment (LDI) by domestic businesses and individuals strengthens the internal economy. This requires fostering an environment encouraging entrepreneurship, supporting startups, and providing resources for homegrown businesses to thrive. Pakistan should focus more on the domestic economy than the borrowed or foreign economy. However, the domestic economy should be independent of the unproductive sub-sectors. Overreliance on real estate and speculative investments like buying plots can distort the economy and lead to bubbles. Diversifying investment options to promote productive sectors like manufacturing, technology, and services will yield better long-term results and create sustainable jobs. Therefore, it is essential to grow the lands and manufacture the goods.

Embracing technology is essential for driving productivity and innovation across all sectors. Investing in education, vocational training, and skill development ensures Pakistan has a workforce equipped to thrive in the modern economy. Leveraging digital platforms can further enhance efficiency in government services and private enterprises. The development of research and development sectors will develop the capacity of human resources in Pakistan, which is inevitable for the growth of all sectors. 

As discussed earlier, it should be a principle for the governments of Pakistan not to do business. Yes, providing a social protection system is essential, but not at the cost of doing business. Strategic privatization of state-owned enterprises can improve efficiency, reduce the fiscal burden on the government, and attract private investment. Proper implementation requires transparency, fair valuation of assets, and competitive bidding processes.

Furthermore, a robust legal framework underpins economic stability. An independent judiciary, efficient dispute resolution mechanisms, and unwavering adherence to the rule of law are crucial for protecting property rights, enforcing contracts, and fostering trust among investors.

These ten principles form a roadmap for building a robust and resilient Pakistani economy. Comprehensive reforms that foster effective governance, empower local development, and embrace the potential of its people and technology will pave the way for Pakistan’s more prosperous and secure future. Hence, if the legislature, executive, and judiciary, with all their derived institutions and operations, work efficiently, the economy of Pakistan can be made functional. For that, the bureaucratic model of the economy should be replaced with a specialized model catering to all the sectors of the economy of Pakistan.

Finally, Pakistan’s economic revival hinges on a multi-pronged approach that addresses both internal and external factors. Economic short-, medium–, and long-term plans and strategies are also significant, as well as structural, administrative, legal, and political decisions. Functional economic measures will also set the economy’s direction in the right place. Fiscal policy consolidation is critical. Reducing budget deficits through a combination of increased tax revenue and spending control is crucial. This fosters confidence in the government’s ability to manage its finances and reduces reliance on borrowing. Prioritizing investments in infrastructure, education, and healthcare creates long-term economic benefits, which is vital. It’s important to ensure efficient allocation of resources and minimize wasteful spending. There is a need to cut the size of the federal and provincial governments. Ministries, departments, and institutions must corroborate the schedule IV of the constitution. It will ensure less governmental public expenditure and avoid the perks and privileges of the legislature, executive, and judiciary. Federal and provincial economic, finance, and planning institutions should play a key role in developing all the sectors of the economy.

Inflation is one of the major obstacles not only for the people but also for the businesses as it enhances the cost of production. Unfavorable COP will make national and international businesses uncompetitive. Furthermore, setting interest rates strategically can help control inflation. Higher interest rates can discourage borrowing and slow down economic activity, but they can also attract foreign investment. Conversely, lower interest rates can stimulate borrowing and investment but risk stoking inflation. Finding the right balance is key. The market should determine the value of currency rather than the government itself. Therefore, the State Bank of Pakistan should allow liberal policies and progressively regulate the financial markets. Giving the market a natural flow is critical for a productive economy. 

Maintaining stable and predictable interest rates over time encourages businesses to invest, knowing their borrowing costs will remain relatively stable. This fosters economic growth and job creation. Encouraging exports and reducing non-essential imports can improve the balance of payments. This can be achieved by promoting export-oriented industries, providing incentives for exporters, and negotiating favorable trade agreements. Facilitating easier channels for overseas Pakistanis to send money back home can increase foreign currency inflows. Additionally, promoting financial inclusion can ensure these remittances reach families and contribute to local economic activity.

Maintaining healthy foreign reserves provides a cushion against external shocks, such as fluctuations in global oil prices or economic downturns. This allows the government to stabilize the exchange rate and manage potential crises. Reducing external debt obligations can free up resources for domestic investments and reduce the burden of interest payments. This can be achieved through a combination of debt restructuring, promoting exports to generate foreign currency earnings, and attracting foreign direct investment. Reliance on a few export products leaves Pakistan vulnerable to price fluctuations in those commodities. Promoting diversification into new export markets and products mitigates this risk and strengthens the overall trade balance. Furthermore, investing in infrastructure development, skills training, and technological advancements can enhance the competitiveness of Pakistani exports in the global market. This can lead to increased export volumes and higher export earnings.

Attracting Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is a double-edged sword. It benefits for a short period. Accordingly, creating a business-friendly environment with clear regulations, political stability, and a skilled workforce can attract FDI. This brings in foreign capital, technology, and expertise, which can boost economic growth and create jobs. Besides, it is of paramount importance that local investments be encouraged for domestic production. Then, promoting investment by domestic businesses and individuals can foster a sense of ownership and encourage long-term economic growth. This can be achieved by providing access to credit, fostering innovation, and simplifying business regulations.

Pakistan can create a more stable and sustainable economic environment by diligently focusing on these economic measures. Improved fiscal policy, responsible interest rate management, and a healthy balance of payments will attract foreign investment and create opportunities for domestic businesses to thrive. This holistic approach, coupled with a focus on export diversification and attracting capital flows, will pave the way for a brighter economic future for Pakistan. Hence, economic revival will only occur with political stability and consistent economic policies reflecting innovation, reforms, and the development of scientific and technological standards in all four sectors of the economy. 

Please, subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com