Abdul Rehman Niazi
In today’s competitive global economy, a nation’s ability to thrive hinges on its capacity to access, adapt, and generate knowledge, especially in the realm of technology. The ability to harness external technological knowledge, integrate it into local industries, and foster innovation is critical for achieving industrial diversification, value addition, and overall competitiveness. However, despite the growing importance of research and development (R&D) in shaping economic futures, Pakistan is falling significantly behind in the global race for innovation.
Public R&D funding plays an essential role in advancing scientific research, improving teaching quality, and building critical infrastructure. At the same time, private sector R&D spending is equally crucial for fostering innovation at the firm level, enabling businesses to enhance their technological capacities. Globally, private sector spending on R&D has surged, far outpacing public investment. For instance, in 2012, global R&D expenditure was estimated at $2.6 trillion, with private companies accounting for about two-thirds, while governments contributed only a third. This shift is evident in many countries, particularly in the OECD, China, and other rapidly developing nations, where private business R&D expenditure far surpasses public funding. In stark contrast, Pakistan’s private sector R&D expenditure is nearly non-existent.
Currently, Pakistan’s total R&D spending stands at a mere 0.16% of GDP, a figure that is alarmingly low when compared to neighboring countries. India spends 0.8% of its GDP on R&D, while China dedicates 2.65%, and South Korea leads with 5.2%. Notably, Pakistan’s business R&D contribution remains insignificant, and the public R&D funding system allocates around 60% of its resources to defense research, leaving little room for crucial sectors like education, healthcare, and technological advancement. Unlike China and South Korea, where the majority of R&D spending is channeled into product development, Pakistan’s R&D efforts lack a clear focus on transforming research into commercially viable products.
A critical flaw in Pakistan’s innovation landscape is the absence of policies to incentivize private sector R&D. There are no tax credits, tax allowances, or innovation grants that could spur business investment in research. Additionally, collaborations between academia and industry are sparse, largely due to the lack of bridging institutions such as incubators and technology parks. Moreover, the country lacks a legal framework that would protect intellectual property (IP) rights resulting from publicly funded research, unlike the US Bayh-Dole Act, which has proven effective in facilitating technology transfer and commercialization.
While transnational corporations (TNCs) offer significant potential for boosting R&D in developing countries, Pakistan has not capitalized on this opportunity. Historically, TNCs limited their R&D efforts in emerging markets to simple product modifications. However, a shift is underway as many global companies are now establishing R&D centers in countries with abundant skilled labor and lower operating costs. China and India have successfully attracted TNC-led R&D, with companies setting up research facilities to tap into local talent pools. Pakistan, however, has neither encouraged technology transfer from TNCs nor facilitated the establishment of R&D centers within the country.
A crucial element missing in Pakistan’s innovation ecosystem is the mobilization of its diaspora networks. Countries like Taiwan and India have seen tremendous success by leveraging their expatriate communities, who have significantly contributed to industries such as IT and electronics. Pakistan, on the other hand, has not actively engaged its diaspora to bring knowledge, skills, and investments back home, limiting its potential for growth in high-tech sectors.
Public policy, particularly in East Asian nations, plays a vital role in fostering business innovation. China, for example, started comprehensive reforms in its public science and technology sectors in the late 1970s. These reforms focused on reforming funding systems, improving R&D management, and strengthening connections between research institutions and industries. Public funding for research institutions was reduced, which encouraged these institutions to seek alternative sources of income through contract research and consultancy. Additionally, China introduced incentives to promote applied research, such as licensing technologies and establishing on-site manufacturing.
Other East Asian countries, such as Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore, have also excelled by prioritizing R&D investment in key industries. Japan’s post-war economic success was largely driven by enhancing the technological capabilities of private companies through public R&D initiatives. These investments allowed Japan to dominate sectors like electronics and transportation. Similarly, South Korea, Taiwan, and Singapore adopted “learning strategies” that promoted firm-level innovation. These governments encouraged local firms to license foreign technology, which allowed them to learn from their foreign counterparts, ultimately helping them to build independent R&D capabilities and shift toward self-reliance in design and engineering.
Moreover, these countries made substantial investments in human resource development, focusing on training scientists, engineers, and technicians. This, in turn, nurtured an environment conducive to innovation. By the 1990s, these nations had developed large-scale R&D programs that fostered incremental innovation and indigenous product development, which eventually enabled local companies to sell products under their own brands. This shift away from dependency on foreign technology marked a critical milestone in their innovation journeys.
Pl subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com for quality podcasts:
Pakistan’s pathway to a knowledge-driven economy could benefit significantly from these successful strategies. A comprehensive, long-term vision is needed, one that focuses on nurturing innovation and competitiveness through a concerted effort between the government, private sector, academia, and the broader society. Pakistan’s economic policies should prioritize private sector R&D, foster stronger industry-academia partnerships, and create a culture of innovation within businesses. The creation of technology hubs, incubation centers, and stronger intellectual property laws could provide the necessary framework to support innovation.
The government must also work towards strengthening public-private partnerships, leveraging the expertise and capital of the diaspora, and promoting international collaboration to access global knowledge networks. Pakistan must also focus on nurturing its human capital by investing in education, particularly in STEM fields, to develop the necessary skills for a knowledge-driven economy.
However, the real challenge lies in the political will to implement these reforms. Political leaders in Pakistan have historically failed to make bold decisions in favor of long-term national growth, primarily due to the vested interests of entrenched elites. Feudal politicians, who dominate the political landscape, are unlikely to support reforms that could threaten their power base. The transformation of Pakistan’s innovation ecosystem will require visionary leadership—one that understands the importance of technology, education, and global competitiveness.
For Pakistan to emerge as a leader in innovation and economic growth, it needs a paradigm shift in governance. This includes embracing technological advancement, nurturing a skilled workforce, and fostering an entrepreneurial spirit. With the right leadership, commitment, and investments in R&D, Pakistan can position itself as a knowledge-driven economy, unlocking its full potential and achieving sustained growth in the global marketplace.