Putting the Cart Before the Donkey: The Failed Water and Sanitation Policies in Pakistan

Pakistan’s urban areas are notorious for their poor governance and lack of adequate services. This is particularly true for the country’s largest city, Karachi, but the problem is by no means limited to that metropolis alone. Lahore, for example, has recently come under scrutiny for its poor water quality and contamination issues.The Action Research Collective (ARC), a group that advocates for better urban service delivery, recently released a report detailing the extent of Lahore’s water crisis. The study found that water samples collected from 400 different locations revealed six major E.coli hotspots in the city. The neighbourhoods of Chungi Amer Sidhu, Charar, Kirianwala, Kharas Mohalla, Kot Khwaja Saeed and Mustafabad all showed evidence of faecal contamination in the water supply. In one of these neighbourhoods, more than a third of residents complained of gastro issues and skin infections in the preceding two weeks. Meanwhile, in Chungi, a staggering 45 per cent of water samples collected showed E.coli contamination.These findings are alarming, to say the least. They highlight the urgent need for Lahore’s authorities to take action to address the city’s water crisis. At the same time, they also underscore the broader challenges facing urban areas in Pakistan.One of the key issues is the opaque and centralised nature of governance in Pakistani cities. Too often, decision-making is concentrated in the hands of a small group of bureaucrats, leaving residents feeling powerless and excluded from the decision-making process. This can lead to a lack of accountability and transparency, which in turn can contribute to the mismanagement of essential services like water supply.Another problem is the lack of investment in infrastructure and public services. In many cases, urban areas in Pakistan are growing rapidly, but the government has failed to keep pace with this growth. As a result, residents are left without access to basic services like clean water, sanitation, and healthcare.These issues are not unique to Pakistan, of course. Many cities in developing countries struggle with similar challenges. However, the situation in Pakistan is particularly acute, and the consequences of urban mismanagement can be severe. In addition to the health risks posed by contaminated water, there are also economic and social consequences to consider. If cities are not able to provide their residents with basic services and infrastructure, this can hinder economic growth, exacerbate inequality, and fuel social unrest.So what can be done to address these challenges? One important step is to empower residents and local communities to participate in decision-making processes. This can be done through initiatives like participatory budgeting, which allows residents to have a say in how public funds are allocated. Another key approach is to invest in infrastructure and public services, with a particular focus on areas that have been historically neglected.Ultimately, though, the challenges facing urban areas in Pakistan are complex and multifaceted, and they require a sustained and coordinated effort from government, civil society, and the private sector. The recent report on Lahore’s water crisis is a stark reminder of just how urgent these challenges are. It is up to all of us to work together to ensure that Pakistan’s cities are able to provide their residents with the services and infrastructure they need to thrive.

ARC, a research collective advocating for better urban service delivery, has recently brought to light yet another example of the misgovernance and neglect that plagues cities in Pakistan. This time, it’s the issue of chronic lead exposure in the industrial neighbourhood of Shadi Pura in Lahore that is under scrutiny.

According to earlier research conducted by ARC-affiliated researchers, residents of Shadi Pura are suffering from lead poisoning, with symptoms including fatigue, muscle pain, and headache. Women are particularly at risk, with a staggering 44% reporting miscarriages. Iron deficiency anemia is also widespread among all sub-groups, with male children being the most affected at 93%. This situation would be considered a public health emergency in any other context.

But the problem is not just limited to lead poisoning. Recent research by ARC has highlighted the poor water quality and contamination in Lahore, particularly in low-income areas. Water samples from 400 locations revealed six major E.coli hotspots, with fecal contamination found in Chungi Amer Sidhu, Charar, Kirianwala, Kharas Mohalla, Kot Khwaja Saeed, and Mustafabad. In Chungi alone, 45% of all samples collected showed E.coli contamination. As a result, more than a third of residents in one of these neighborhoods complained of gastro issues and skin infections in just the preceding two weeks.

It’s clear that the governing structures of Pakistani cities are opaque, centralized, and rigidly bureaucratic, resulting in a failure to meet the needs of large swathes of residents. Karachi is the most obvious case of urban misgovernance, but similar stories of decay can be found all over the country, including Lahore.

What’s particularly alarming is that the contaminants are found almost exclusively in low-income areas, particularly former village settlements that have been engulfed by the city over time. The water samples collected from high-income areas such as DHA, Gulberg, Model Town, and Johar Town do not show fecal contamination. This disparity underscores the issue of environmental injustice, as it is the most vulnerable members of society who are bearing the brunt of poor governance and neglect.

It’s not just the responsibility of the government to address these issues. Citizens must also take an active role in advocating for their rights to clean water, air, and a healthy environment. Civil society organizations like ARC are doing crucial work in shining a light on these issues and advocating for change. But it’s up to all of us to demand better from our leaders and hold them accountable for their actions, or lack thereof.

Read more:

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest Videos