Naveed Hussain
Federalism, a mode of political organization that brings together separate states or polities within a broader political framework, is a system that values negotiation. It allows each entity to maintain its own integrity by mandating that fundamental policies are formulated and implemented through negotiations. This enables all members to actively participate in the decision-making and execution process, emphasizing the importance of your role in the system. The political principles underlying federal systems highlight the value of dispersed power centers as a means to protect individual and local freedoms.
While there are various political systems that identify as federal, there are certain characteristics and principles that are common to all genuinely federal systems.
First and foremost, the federal relationship must be established or reaffirmed through a perpetual union agreement, often enshrined in a written constitution that outlines the terms for sharing or dividing power. The constitution can only be amended through extraordinary procedures. These constitutions are distinct in that they are not simply agreements between rulers and the ruled, but involve the people, the central government, and the states that constitute the federal union. Additionally, the constituent states often retain the right to create their own constitutions.
Secondly, the political system itself must reflect the constitution by diffusing power among several largely self-sufficient centers. This diffusion of power is termed noncentralization, serving to ensure in practice that the authority to participate in exercising political power cannot be withdrawn from the general or state governments without mutual consent.
A crucial element of any federal system is what has been termed territorial democracy. This concept involves the use of geographical divisions to ensure impartiality and equality in representing various groups and interests in the polity, as well as to secure local autonomy and representation for diverse groups within the same civil society. Territorial democracy ensures that all regions, regardless of their population or economic power, have a say in the governance of the country. This system has proven to be highly effective in allowing for the representation of new interests by enabling their supporters to vote in relatively equal territorial units. Additionally, it has facilitated the accommodation of fundamentally diverse groups by providing them with territorial power bases of their own, enhancing the ability of federal systems to function as vehicles of political integration while preserving democratic governance.
Modern federal systems establish direct lines of communication between the citizenry and all levels of government. The people elect representatives to all government levels, and all levels administer programs that directly benefit individual citizens. This establishment of direct lines of communication is based on a sense of common nationality that binds the constituent entities and people together. Your role as a citizen is crucial in maintaining the unity within federal systems. Geographic factors such as rivers, mountains, and the need for common defense against shared adversaries also play a role in promoting the maintenance of union within federal systems.
Pl subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com
It is important to maintain noncentralization in a federal system, ensuring that the constituent polities are fairly balanced in terms of population, wealth, and geographic representation. For instance, in the United States, each geographic section includes both large and small states, preventing any one state from dominating the others. Similarly, in Canada, the differences between the two largest provinces have prevented them from combining against the others, supporting the notion of noncentralization. Successful federal systems have historically been characterized by the permanent nature of their internal boundaries and, in some cases, the constitutionally guaranteed existence of different systems of law in the constituent polities, contributing to substantial noncentralization.
Furthermore, a truly federal system requires substantial influence of the constituent polities over the formal or informal constitutional-amending process. This ensures that significant changes in the political order can only be made with the decision of dispersed majorities that reflect the division of powers. Your collective voice as part of the dispersed majorities is what emphasizes the importance of popular government and federalism. The existence of a noncentralized party system also plays a crucial role in maintaining federal noncentralization, functioning as a decentralizing force in its own right.
Several devices found in federal systems serve to maintain the federal principle itself. One of the key requirements for maintaining federalism is that both the central government and the constituent polities have substantially complete governing institutions of their own, with the right to modify those institutions within limits set by the compact. This ‘compact’ refers to the agreement or contract that outlines the powers and responsibilities of each level of government. Additionally, the contractual sharing of public responsibilities by all governments in the system is fundamental to federalism, including common involvement in policy-making, financing, and administration. This sharing, whether formal or informal, serves as a legal device to enable governments to engage in joint action while remaining independent entities, further supporting the federal principle.
Accordingly, the successful operation of federal systems requires conducive political environments that promote popular government, traditions of political cooperation, and self-restraint. Federal systems operate best in societies with sufficient homogeneity of fundamental interests to allow for local government autonomy and voluntary collaboration. It is essential to note that federal systems are most successful in societies that have the human and material resources to support the maintenance of federal patterns of government.
Pakistan is a federal state, and it is essential to run it as a federal state rather than a unitary state. The federal system in Pakistan ensures the distribution of power between the central government and the provincial governments, allowing each province to have its own autonomy and a say in the decision-making process. This distribution of power is crucial in accommodating the diversity within the country, as Pakistan is home to various ethnicities, cultures, and languages.
In a federal system like Pakistan, the provincial governments have the authority to make decisions on matters that directly impact their constituents, such as education, healthcare, and local infrastructure. This decentralized approach allows for more effective governance, as decisions can be tailored to meet the specific needs of each province.
Furthermore, the federal structure helps in creating a sense of inclusivity and participation among the diverse regions of Pakistan. By granting a degree of autonomy to the provinces, the federal system acknowledges and respects the unique identities and interests of different regions within the country.
It is important to note that maintaining Pakistan as a federal state is vital for national cohesion and stability. By allowing each province to have a stake in the decision-making process and governance, the federal system promotes a sense of ownership and belonging among the people of Pakistan. This, in turn, contributes to the overall unity and strength of the nation.
In summary, operating Pakistan as a federal state provides a framework for accommodating its diverse population, promoting effective governance, and fostering national unity. Therefore, it is imperative to uphold and strengthen the federal system to ensure the equitable representation and participation of all regions within the country.
