Nadeem-ul-Haque
Three conferences on Pakistan have been held, or are about to be, on three of America’s most famous campuses: Harvard in April, Georgetown last weekend, the University of Chicago this weekend. The names impress. They should not mislead.
These are not Harvard’s, Georgetown’s or Chicago’s conferences. They are organised by Pakistani students who book a hall on campus. The university lends a room and, unavoidably, its name. A research centre may add its logo. No faculty sets the agenda, reviews the content or stands behind what is said. Harvard’s own South Asia institute has said as much of its student conferences: the student organisers decide the topics and the speakers.
The money is Pakistani too. Georgetown’s sponsors were led by The Bank of Punjab, which belongs to the Punjab government, along with Pakistani-American business councils and foundations. The main sponsor of Harvard’s first edition was a Pakistani food company. Chicago lists Pakistan’s embassy and consulate among its partners. So the agenda is set by Pakistani students and their Pakistani sponsors. It is no surprise that it looks so much like Islamabad.
Look at who is invited. Harvard had the finance minister. Chicago is billing the planning minister, a minister of state and a Punjab provincial minister. Georgetown had former ministers and the chief executive of the bank that paid for the event. Around them sit the glitterati. Harvard’s closing keynote went to a film star, with a fashion designer and musicians on a culture panel. Georgetown featured a filmmaker and a podcaster. Chicago ends each evening with a ticketed concert.
Why the ministers? These are the people responsible for the mess. The planning minister has held that portfolio in three governments since 2013. Are the students calling him to hear him, or to check him on his policies, or the lack of them? The format gives the answer. There is no paper for him to respond to, no discussant, and no critic beside him. He will speak, be applauded and be photographed. He will fly home with the prestige of a Chicago stage, and without having answered a single hard question.
The critics and the researchers are not invited. The speaker lists at Georgetown and Chicago include no one from PIDE, LUMS or IBA, the places where Pakistan’s economy is actually studied. Harvard was the one exception: it sat two academic economists beside the finance minister. That is what every session should do. Even there it was a panel, with no paper to hold anyone to.
And the burning issues of the day went unaddressed. The country is arguing over new provinces. Civil service reform has been promised for decades and not delivered. The powerful interior minister has just announced that Islamabad has a severe shortage of hotels, and that a seized tower on Constitution Avenue will become a five-star one. What does that tell us about how the state thinks about cities, property and investment? We are in our 25th IMF programme, and nobody has a plan for graduating from the Fund. The energy problem is ever present, with circular debt in the power sector of about Rs 1.6 trillion.
None of the three built a session around any of this. Chicago does list a track on federalism. The man due to answer is the planning minister, and there is no paper on the table.
I have written elsewhere about our conferences at home. They always keep away from a reform narrative. I had hoped that students abroad, far from the ministries, would do better. Instead they have imported the Islamabad model and given it a grander backdrop.
The students have energy, reach and an audience that no hall in Islamabad can match. They should use them. Invite the critics and the researchers. Put the minister in the chair that answers questions. Give each session one hard question, such as whether new provinces would pay for themselves, and someone to argue the other side. Tell the sponsors that paying for the hall does not buy the agenda.
A festival is a fine thing, and there is nothing wrong with a concert. But let us not call it a debate on Pakistan’s future. That debate has still not been held, here or abroad.
Sources
• Harvard Pakistan Conference 2026 showcases nation’s resilience, Bol News, Apr 2026
• Stars in the US for Pakistan Conference at Harvard, Dawn Images, Apr 2026
• Mittal Institute statement on student-run conferences, Harvard, Apr 2025
• National Foods Limited at the Pakistan Conference 2025 at Harvard, Business Recorder, 2025
• Georgetown Pakistan Forum and its speakers
• Pakistan Summit 2026, Chicago: team, speakers and partners
• Naqvi says One Constitution Avenue to be converted into five-star hotel, Express Tribune, Nov 2026
• Pakistan’s conference economy: research for reform or extravaganza?, Business Recorder, Nov 2026








