Arshad Mahmood Awan
Pakistanis finally have some good news about their electricity bills. The government has announced price reductions for homes, businesses, and industries. These cuts will last for three months and come from three main sources: fuel cost adjustments, quarterly tariff revisions, and subsidies funded by taxes on petroleum. On the surface, this looks like progress. But dig deeper, and you’ll find these are just quick fixes that don’t solve the energy sector’s real problems.
Several factors are helping lower power prices temporarily. First, Pakistan’s overall economy has stabilized somewhat, with inflation slowing and interest rates coming down. This makes borrowing cheaper for power companies. Second, global oil prices have been relatively stable, and the government has kept petroleum taxes high (Rs. 70 per liter). Since Pakistan imports most of its oil, taxing fuel allows some relief for electricity consumers.
Some of these price reductions might stick around next year if economic conditions stay stable. The adjustments tied to power generation contracts and currency exchange rates could become permanent parts of the pricing structure. But here’s the catch – none of this addresses the broken parts of Pakistan’s energy system that keep causing blackouts, debt, and inefficiency.
Pakistan has an unusual energy situation. We have some of the lowest petrol prices in our region but pay extremely high electricity rates. The government is now using taxes on fuel to subsidize power costs. This makes sense because Pakistan wastes money importing oil while having extra electricity capacity that isn’t being fully used.
If global oil prices drop further – which might happen due to trade wars and new US tariffs – the government could increase fuel taxes even more to keep electricity prices down. But there’s a limit to this strategy. Current laws cap the petroleum tax at Rs. 70 per liter. To go beyond that, the government needs parliament’s approval in the next budget.
With gas prices skyrocketing, many industries want to switch from gas generators to grid electricity. This shift could help Pakistan in three ways: using our existing power plants more, reducing expensive gas imports, and cutting pollution. But there’s a big problem – our electrical grid keeps failing.
Industrial areas, especially in Punjab, suffer from frequent power trips and outages. Every time the power cuts out, factories lose money from stopped production and damaged equipment. While K-Electric in Karachi has made some improvements, most government-run power distribution companies (DISCOs) haven’t fixed these reliability issues. Until they do, industries won’t fully trust and switch to grid power.
Even with these price cuts, Pakistan’s energy sector is still drowning in debt. Here’s why:
First, power theft remains rampant in many areas. Some DISCOs only collect payments for 60-70% of the electricity they distribute. The rest gets stolen or lost in crumbling infrastructure. Second, our transmission systems waste too much power – far more than what’s considered acceptable. Every year, these losses add billions to the national debt.
This situation is like trying to fill a bucket with a giant hole in the bottom. No matter how much we adjust prices or find clever funding tricks, the losses keep draining away any progress.
Pl subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com for quality podcasts:
What Actually Needs to Happen
Price reductions help people’s budgets in the short term, but Pakistan needs fundamental changes:
- Stop the Bleeding: The government must crack down on power theft and force DISCOs to improve their collection rates. There’s no excuse for losing 30-40% of distributed electricity.
- Fix the Broken Grid: Industries won’t switch from gas to electricity until they can count on stable power. Major investments are needed to upgrade transmission lines and substations, especially in industrial zones.
- Make Tough Decisions on DISCOs: Some power distribution companies may need to be privatized or completely restructured. The current system rewards inefficiency and punishes well-run utilities like K-Electric.
- Long-Term Pricing Strategy: While using fuel taxes to lower electricity costs works now, Pakistan needs a sustainable pricing model that doesn’t rely on temporary tricks.
The recent electricity price cuts provide welcome relief for consumers and businesses struggling with high costs. But these are temporary measures that don’t fix the energy sector’s structural problems. Until Pakistan tackles power theft, upgrades its failing grid, and reforms its DISCOs, we’ll keep cycling between short-term solutions and long-term crises.
The government has a choice: keep applying band-aids to the energy sector’s wounds, or finally perform the major surgery it needs. The path they choose will determine whether Pakistan’s power system becomes an engine for economic growth or remains a drag on the nation’s development for years to come.
