Editorial
The recent Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meeting on December 12th, 2023, presented a perplexing scenario. Despite acknowledging a staggering 1108.59% increase in gas prices and stubbornly persistent inflation, the Committee opted to maintain the discount rate at 22%. This decision warrants closer scrutiny, as it raises several critical questions about the state of Pakistan’s economy and the effectiveness of current monetary policy approaches.
The experts rightfully point out that the MPC’s expectation of falling inflation has not materialized. Headline inflation, which stood at 28.3% in July, rose to 29.2% in November despite three consecutive meetings where the policy rate remained unchanged. Core inflation, too, contradicts the optimistic projections in the monetary policy statement, inching up from 18.5% in October to 18.6% in November. These discrepancies raise concerns about the accuracy of official inflation data, with independent reports and surveys suggesting a more pessimistic picture.
The reliance on administrative measures pledged under the IMF’s Stand-By Arrangement (SBA) as justification for the unchanged rate further complicates the situation. Meanwhile, the claimed improvements in worker remittances and successful completion of the SBA’s first review might seem encouraging. The surge in remittances in October appears temporary, potentially driven by government incentives and masking the underlying suppression in October 2022 due to policy missteps. Similarly, the promised “unlocking of financial inflows” upon completing the first review remains elusive, with crucial upgrades from rating agencies and anticipated foreign inflows yet to materialize.
Please, subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com
The increase in tax and non-tax revenue is indeed commendable. However, the continued reliance on the petroleum levy, a regressive tax disproportionately impacting the less privileged, raises ethical concerns. The economists aptly highlight the need for broader tax base expansion and a more equitable distribution of the tax burden. The MPC’s optimism based on consumer and business confidence surveys and declining broad money growth appears fragile. The continued constraints on raw materials imports contradict the positive sentiment, while exporters publicly express their struggles against high energy costs. The IMF’s own cautionary note about the soundness of the banking system adds further weight to these concerns.
Then, the government’s current focus on administrative measures for the SBA, while necessary, is insufficient. Genuine structural reforms are paramount to achieving sustainable macroeconomic stability. Only then can Pakistan’s economy truly escape the grip of high inflation and begin to thrive on a solid foundation.
In summary, the MPC’s decision to maintain the discount rate presents a complex picture. While acknowledging critical issues, it remains unclear whether the chosen path will effectively address them. The need for transparency, accurate data, and a shift towards structural reforms is more pressing than ever. Only through such a comprehensive approach can Pakistan navigate the current economic challenges and build a future of sustainable growth and stability.
Please, subscribe to the monthly magazines of republicpolicy.com
