Editorial
Pakistan’s constitutional amendments have a troubling habit of saying one thing and doing another. The latest echo surrounding the Twenty-Eighth Amendment is a perfect example of this institutional dishonesty.
On one hand, there is talk of strengthening local government through constitutional protection. On the other hand, the same amendment carries whispers of establishing a unified central civil service. These two objectives do not merely differ in emphasis. They directly contradict each other. You cannot simultaneously hand power to local governments and then place those governments under a bureaucratic structure that answers to the centre. The contradiction is not incidental. It is structural.
The deepest administrative reason why local government has perpetually failed in Pakistan is one that officialdom refuses to acknowledge honestly: there is no Local Government Service. Local bodies have never been given their own dedicated, trained, and accountable civil servants. They have always been managed by officers whose careers, loyalties, and promotions belong to provincial or federal hierarchies. An officer who owes nothing to the local council and everything to his departmental superiors in the capital will never genuinely serve local interests. This is not a character failing. It is a systemic one.
Now, instead of correcting this failure by creating a genuine Local Government Service, the bureaucracy is pushing in the opposite direction. A unified central civil service would not empower local governments. It would formally subordinate them, permanently and constitutionally, to administrative structures they do not control.
This pattern has been seen before. The previous constitutional amendment was used to restore executive magistracy, a colonial instrument with no place in democratic governance. The bureaucracy has proven repeatedly that it treats constitutional amendments as tools for self-preservation, not national reform.
Pakistan deserves better. Real reform means a Local Government Service, genuine provincial autonomy, and a civil service that serves the constitution rather than circumventing it.
Books by Republic Policy Think Tank on civil service and governance reform are available at Vanguard Books and all leading book centres.
