Editorial
Foreign aid has long been the lifeblood for many developing nations, including Pakistan, funding critical sectors like health, education, and infrastructure. These pillars are vital for fostering growth and stability. Yet, despite billions in aid over decades, the results remain disappointing. This raises a critical question: where did we go wrong, and how can we escape this cycle of dependency?
Pakistan, since 1951, has secured over $200 billion in foreign aid, though only $155 to $170 billion has actually materialized. Despite this influx, there has been minimal progress in key socio-economic indicators, such as the Human Development Index (HDI). The problem lies not in the amount of aid, but in its management and allocation.
Pl watch the video and subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com for quality podcasts:
The inefficiency of aid distribution is a glaring issue. The Economic Affairs Division (EAD) and Finance Division manage the inflows, but inconsistencies in reporting and a lack of transparency have resulted in mismanagement and waste. Aid agreements are often shrouded in secrecy, fueling doubts about their true impact. In fact, foreign aid accounts for a large portion of Pakistan’s Public Sector Development Program (PSDP), but the outcomes have been underwhelming. In the past decade, 1,268 aid-funded projects have been launched, most of which are incomplete or fail to deliver substantial benefits.
A major issue is the “tied aid” that restricts spending to donor countries’ goods and services, inflating costs and limiting flexibility. For instance, despite $12 billion allocated to health and education between 2004 and 2020, Pakistan’s HDI showed negligible improvement. Additionally, the heavy reliance on consultants, often selected by donor nations, diverts attention from tangible progress to reports and studies.
The result is a vicious cycle: inefficiencies in aid usage increase external debt, widen inequalities, and fuel mistrust in the system. To break this cycle, stronger regulations, transparency, and real-time reporting are essential. Leveraging technology like data analytics and blockchain could provide much-needed accountability.
Foreign aid should be a tool for empowerment, not a tool for perpetuating dependence. If Pakistan is serious about escaping this cycle, it must reform its approach to aid management and prioritize long-term growth and equity over quick fixes. The question remains: are we ready to make the necessary changes, or will we continue down the same path?
