Nadeem-ul-Haque
Building Social Capital, a three-part series. Part 1: Part 1: AI Needs the Mohalla — Artificial Intelligence and Social Capital. Part 2: education failure (this article). Part 3: Part 3: The Mohalla Learning Centre — A Proposal.
Schooling has failed on its own terms
Pakistan’s school system fails by the only measures it uses, enrolment and certificates, and ignores the measures that matter: learning, curiosity, discipline and the ability to work with others. For two decades policy has counted classrooms, enrolment drives and textbook boards. The result is more children out of school than ever, most of those in school unable to read, and a state now spending less on education than before it declared an emergency.
This is not a failure of effort alone. It is a failure of model. We have treated education as the delivery of content through a building, when content is now the cheapest input there is.
Out of school, and not learning in it
About 26.2 million Pakistani children are out of school, the second-largest number in the world, and three in four of those enrolled cannot read a simple text by age ten.
The Ministry of Education’s girls’ education statistics report (GESTR 2023-24, released February 2026) counts 25.37 million children aged 5 to 16 out of school, 13.41 million of them girls (Express Tribune). Punjab alone has 9.6 million, Sindh 7.82 million, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa 4.92 million and Balochistan 2.94 million. All this comes more than two years after a National Education Emergency was declared.
The pipeline leaks at every stage. About 20.8 million children enrol at primary, 9.2 million at middle, 4.7 million at matric and 2.8 million at intermediate (same source). Fewer than one in seven primary entrants reach intermediate.
Those who stay mostly do not learn. The World Bank puts learning poverty at 77%, meaning three in four children cannot read and understand a simple text by age ten; this is far worse than Bangladesh, India or Sri Lanka (World Bank). Only about half of students can solve a two-digit arithmetic problem (Dawn). Enrolment without learning is not education. It is attendance.
A shrinking state chasing a new slogan
The state is spending less on education while announcing bigger plans for it. Education spending fell to 0.8% of GDP in FY2024-25, from 1.5% in FY23, according to the Pakistan Economic Survey 2025-26 (Profit).
The new slogan is AI. Punjab has approved AI as a subject from Class I to XII, with QR codes on textbooks linking to video lessons (Express Tribune). It plans to train 160,000 teachers (ProPakistani) and to spend Rs 81 crore on two showcase AI schools in Lahore (ProPakistani).
Yet the primary-school rollout has already stalled, because thousands of government schools lack computers, internet access and trained teachers (ProPakistani). The pattern is familiar. A curriculum is written in sixty days; the conditions that make it usable are left for later.
The deeper error is conceptual. Punjab is teaching AI as a subject when its real value is as a tutor, and Part 1 shows that AI tutors work only in supervised, scheduled, shared settings. Classrooms built for rote instruction, with no power, devices or bandwidth, are not those settings.
Nowhere to learn outside the classroom
Outside school, most Pakistanis have no library, no playground and no association to belong to. Learning that schools fail to provide cannot be made up anywhere else.
Durr-e-Nayab’s PIDE-BASICS survey measured access to the basic facilities of a learning society (BASICS Notes 6; BASICS Notes 5):

The striking finding is the library gap among the rich. Even in the richest fifth, nearly three in four Pakistanis have no library. This is not a problem that household income will solve. It is a failure of public provision, and only public provision can correct it.
Nayab ends her engagement note with the right question: if people are not socially engaged, where are they keeping their minds and bodies alive? For most Pakistanis the answer is the phone. Without shared places, the phone becomes the library, the playground and the club, and AI on that phone will entertain far more than it educates.
What schooling ignores, and what follows
The system measures what is easy to count and neglects what makes learning stick. Even when children complete school, questions remain about their attitude to discipline, collaboration, responsibility and accountability. Our leaders are the evidence. The English public schools that trained the East India Company’s administrators understood this; they built esprit de corps through team sports, societies and shared responsibility. We copied the syllabus and dropped the rest.
Three conclusions follow for policy:
1. More buildings of the same kind will not fix this. Twenty years of enrolment drives have produced 26 million out-of-school children and 77% learning poverty.
2. The scarce input is no longer content. AI supplies explanation at near-zero cost. What is scarce is time on task, supervision, motivation and peers, which are social goods.
3. Learning must leave the classroom. Children need places after school, and adults need places at all, where they can study, play, read and build things together.
Pakistan does not need another curriculum reform. It needs social infrastructure. Part 3 proposes what that should look like in every urban mohalla.
Sources
• 26m children out of school in Pakistan (GESTR 2023-24), Express Tribune, Feb 2026
• Five major challenges to girls’ education in Pakistan, World Bank, 2024
• Even with more children attending school, Pakistan is struggling with a learning crisis, Dawn, 2023
• Education spending drops to 0.8% of GDP, Profit, Jun 2026
• Punjab approves new curriculum with AI from Class I, Express Tribune, Sep 2026
• Punjab to train 160,000 teachers under AI curriculum, ProPakistani, Sep 2026
• Punjab plans two AI schools in Lahore, ProPakistani, Jun 2026
• Punjab failed to launch AI classes as schools lack basic technology, ProPakistani, Jul 2026
• Shaping Minds and Bodies: Do We Have the Facilities? (BASICS Notes 6), Durr-e-Nayab, PIDE, 2023
• Social and Civic Engagement (BASICS Notes 5), Durr-e-Nayab, PIDE, 2023









