Naveed Ahmad Chaudhry

Devolution: A Conceptual Overview

Devolution, in the context of governance, refers to the transfer of powers and responsibilities from a central government to lower levels of administration, such as provincial or local governments. This process aims to decentralize decision-making and empower local communities to address their specific needs and aspirations more effectively. Devolution is often seen as a crucial step in strengthening democratic institutions and fostering inclusive governance.

The Significance of Administrative, Legislative, Judicial, and Financial Devolution

Administrative devolution entails the delegation of administrative authority from the central government to provincial and local bodies. This empowers local governments to manage their own affairs, including the provision of essential services such as education, healthcare, and infrastructure development. Administrative devolution enhances the responsiveness of governance to local needs and preferences.

Legislative devolution involves granting provincial legislatures the power to enact laws on matters within their jurisdiction. This decentralizes lawmaking and allows provinces to tailor their legal frameworks to their unique circumstances. Legislative devolution promotes regional diversity and facilitates adaptability to local conditions.

Judicial devolution involves the establishment of independent lower courts at the provincial and local levels. This decentralizes the judicial system and brings justice closer to the people. Judicial devolution enhances access to justice, expedites legal proceedings, and promotes a sense of local ownership over the administration of justice.

Financial devolution entails transferring financial resources and revenue-raising powers from the central government to provincial and local bodies. This enables local governments to fund their own development projects and initiatives. Financial devolution empowers local communities to make their own decisions about resource allocation and prioritization.

Implementing Devolution in Pakistan: A Path Forward:

Pakistan has taken significant steps towards devolution, particularly through the passage of the 18th Amendment to the Constitution in 2010. However, the implementation of devolution has been uneven and slow, with challenges remaining in effectively transferring powers and resources to provincial and local governments. To further strengthen devolution in Pakistan, several key measures can be adopted:

1. Strengthening Provincial Autonomy: The central government should consistently respect the constitutional autonomy of provincial governments and refrain from undue interference in their affairs.
2. Enhancing Local Government Capacity: Provincial governments should invest in building the capacity of local governments to manage their responsibilities effectively. This includes providing training, technical assistance, and resources to local officials.
3. Ensuring Financial Autonomy: Provincial and local governments should be granted greater financial autonomy, including the power to raise their own revenues and control their budgets. This will enable them to fund their own development initiatives and reduce reliance on central government transfers.
4. Promoting Transparency and Accountability: Mechanisms should be established to ensure transparency and accountability in the devolution process. This includes regular audits, public scrutiny, and effective grievance redressal mechanisms.
5. Empowering Citizens: Citizen participation and engagement should be actively promoted at the local level. This includes encouraging community participation in decision-making processes and providing avenues for citizens to hold their local governments accountable.
6. Continuous Monitoring and Evaluation: The devolution process should be continuously monitored and evaluated to identify challenges and areas for improvement. This will ensure that devolution is progressing effectively and achieving its intended objectives.

Furthermore, devolution is the process of transferring powers and responsibilities from the central government to the subnational units, such as provinces and local governments. Devolution can enhance the efficiency, responsiveness, and accountability of governance, as well as the participation and representation of the citizens. In Pakistan, devolution has been a constitutional and political challenge since its independence, with various attempts and reforms made by different regimes and governments.

The legislature and the executive are the two main branches of the government that can implement devolution in Pakistan’s governmental structures. The legislature is the lawmaking body that represents the people and their interests. The executive is the branch that implements and enforces the laws and policies made by the legislature. The role of the legislature and the executive in devolution can be explained as follows.

The legislature can enact laws and amendments that define the scope, extent, and mechanism of devolution. For example, the 18th Amendment to the Constitution of Pakistan in 2010 was a landmark legislation that devolved significant powers and functions from the federal to the provincial level, including education, health, environment, and social welfare. The legislature can also pass laws that establish and empower the local governments, such as the Local Government Acts of 2013 and 2019, which provide for the election, structure, and functions of the local councils and authorities in the provinces.

The executive can implement and operationalize the devolution laws and policies made by the legislature. For example, the executive can allocate and transfer the financial resources and administrative staff to the devolved units, as well as monitor and evaluate their performance and accountability. The executive can also facilitate and coordinate the intergovernmental relations and cooperation among the federal, provincial, and local governments, as well as resolve any disputes or conflicts that may arise due to devolution. The executive can also promote and support the participation and engagement of the citizens and civil society in the devolved governance processes.

Therefore, the legislature and the executive can play a vital and complementary role in implementing devolution in the governmental structures in Pakistan. However, this role also requires political will, commitment, and consensus among the different actors and stakeholders involved in the devolution process, as well as respect for the constitutional and democratic principles and values that underpin devolution.

By implementing these measures, Pakistan can further strengthen its devolution framework and reap the benefits of decentralized governance. Devolution can lead to improved service delivery, increased responsiveness to local needs, and greater citizen participation, ultimately contributing to a more inclusive and effective democratic system. Therefore, there is a national movement for the implementation of law and the Constitution in Pakistan for the attainment of devolution. 

Please, subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com