Nadeem Chohan Advocate
Imran Khan’s aspirations for participating in the upcoming February elections suffered a major setback as the Supreme Court declined his urgent plea for an immediate hearing in the Toshakhana case. The court’s decision, citing the lack of available judges due to winter vacations, throws a thick cloud of uncertainty over Khan’s political future.
The crux of Khan’s petition was the suspension of his conviction in the Toshakhana case, which resulted in his disqualification from holding public office for five years. While the Islamabad High Court previously suspended his sentence, the conviction and disqualification remain in effect. Khan’s lawyers argued that suspending the conviction should automatically nullify the disqualification, paving the way for his electoral participation.
However, Justice Athar Minallah swiftly rejected this argument, highlighting the absence of legal precedent for such an outcome. This sets the stage for a potentially protracted legal battle, as Khan needs to challenge the conviction itself to achieve his desired reinstatement in the political arena.
The two-judge bench further complicated matters by refusing to hear the petition, citing the need for a three-member bench due to the complexity of the case and the presence of a conflicting decision by a High Court division bench. This delay, stretching at least until next week when Chief Justice Qazi Faez Isa returns from vacation, throws a wrench into Khan’s already tight electoral timeline.
The legal complexities surrounding Khan’s case are further amplified by the PTI’s separate petition against the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP). This adds another layer of uncertainty to the situation, as any potential rulings in the ECP case could influence or be influenced by the Toshakhana proceedings.
Khan’s lawyers, though disappointed by the court’s delay, argued for summoning additional judges to expedite the hearing. This highlights the urgency and political significance of the case, not only for Khan but for the upcoming elections as a whole. The PTI’s claim that Judge Humayun Dilawar’s swift issuance of five sentences in a single day in the Toshakhana case raises questions about the fairness of the proceedings, potentially adding another layer of legal contention.
In conclusion, the Supreme Court’s decision to delay Imran Khan’s hearing in the Toshakhana case has thrown his political future into limbo. The legal complexities involved, coupled with the additional ECP petition, paint a picture of a potentially lengthy and arduous legal battle. While Khan’s supporters remain hopeful, the delay casts a long shadow over his chances of participating in the upcoming elections, raising questions about the impact on the political landscape and the potential for further legal wrangles in the weeks and months to come.
The next week will be crucial for Khan and his supporters. The Supreme Court’s decision on whether to form a three-member bench to hear his petition will determine his fate in the upcoming elections. While the legal battle continues, the political landscape remains in a state of flux, with all eyes on the apex court and the road ahead for Imran Khan.
Please, subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com
