Fajar Rehman
As Pakistan faces an increasingly dire economic crisis, the average citizen is being asked to bear the weight of austerity measures—cutbacks, rising costs of living, and shrinking purchasing power. While ordinary Pakistanis struggle to make ends meet and put food on the table, lawmakers in the National Assembly seem to be making an entirely different calculation. A recent proposal by the National Assembly’s Finance Committee, which seeks significant pay hikes for members of both the National Assembly and the Senate, has drawn widespread criticism. As the proposal moves forward, it raises a fundamental question: can we justify such pay raises for politicians when the country is on the brink of financial collapse?
The proposal, which is currently with the Prime Minister for approval, suggests increasing the monthly salaries of lawmakers from Rs180,000 to a whopping Rs519,000. While the initial suggestion had been to bring their salaries up to Rs1 million a month, the Speaker of the National Assembly reportedly felt that such an amount would be excessive. However, even the proposed Rs519,000 monthly salary represents a sharp increase that seems disproportionate given Pakistan’s economic situation.
It’s important to note that the last time lawmakers received a raise was seven years ago. While inflation has certainly taken a toll on everyone’s financial stability, it is worth questioning whether this sharp increase in lawmakers’ pay is truly justifiable. After all, Pakistan is not a developed nation where such pay hikes could be expected in return for high-quality public service. Our country is struggling with severe economic challenges, and its financial outlook is far from stable.
Furthermore, the push for higher salaries comes at a time when the government is enacting austerity measures to satisfy the demands of international lenders like the IMF. As part of this austerity, the government has been slashing public sector jobs and curbing public spending. In this context, how can such a substantial raise for lawmakers be morally justified? When the average Pakistani worker is struggling with a monthly minimum wage of Rs37,000, how can those who are supposed to represent their interests justify such a hefty salary increase for themselves?
This issue goes beyond just lawmakers. In fact, many members of Pakistan’s powerful bureaucracy, judiciary, and military enjoy similarly lavish salaries and perks funded by taxpayers. While the average citizen is expected to tighten their belt, these elite sectors continue to receive generous compensation. This, of course, sparks outrage, especially given the widespread poverty and economic insecurity that the majority of Pakistanis endure.
Lawmakers, as representatives of the people, are expected to lead by example. Their role is not just to pass legislation and make decisions that affect the nation; they are also supposed to demonstrate an understanding of the struggles faced by ordinary citizens. In times of financial crisis, when government revenues are stretched thin, such exorbitant pay raises only reinforce the sense that the political elite are disconnected from the reality of life on the ground. The disconnect between the compensation lawmakers receive and the lives of ordinary Pakistanis creates a sense of frustration and distrust toward the political system.
It’s also worth noting that such a pay raise should be part of the regular budgeting process and not something that appears unexpectedly. This sudden proposal for a hefty salary increase suggests a lack of long-term planning and an absence of consideration for the broader financial picture. Salary increases should be integrated into the national budget after proper deliberation, and they should reflect the country’s fiscal health, as well as the current economic challenges faced by citizens.
Pl watch the video and subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com for quality podcasts:
In developed economies where lawmakers are compensated well for their work, their high salaries are typically justified by their performance and the efficiency of the government they represent. In these countries, the public can see a clear link between the service provided by elected officials and the compensation they receive. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for Pakistan. Lawmakers have not delivered on promises to improve governance, strengthen the economy, or effectively address pressing issues such as poverty, unemployment, and corruption.
The issue is not just about the salaries of lawmakers. It is also about the broader culture of entitlement that pervades Pakistan’s political elite. From lavish perks and allowances to enormous security budgets, the country’s political leaders and bureaucrats are enjoying a lifestyle that is out of touch with the lives of ordinary Pakistanis. In many ways, this reflects a wider systemic issue where the political class prioritizes its own interests over the welfare of the public. While Pakistanis are forced to tighten their belts, the elite continue to benefit from the country’s limited resources, often with little to no accountability.
The Prime Minister has a critical decision to make in this regard. He must ensure that any increase in lawmakers’ pay is reasonable, sustainable, and aligned with the needs and realities of the country’s financial situation. While it is not unreasonable to consider a modest raise for lawmakers, the current proposal is far too generous given Pakistan’s economic situation. The government should look for ways to reduce the financial burden on the public sector while ensuring that lawmakers are fairly compensated for their work. However, any increase in their pay must reflect the dire economic conditions faced by the country and should not be seen as a reward for political performance that does not measure up.
In conclusion, while lawmakers deserve fair compensation for their hard work, the proposed pay hike is out of touch with the financial challenges faced by the average Pakistani. Given the economic struggles, rising inflation, and austerity measures implemented by the government, it is hard to justify such a large salary increase for those who are already well-compensated. Pakistan’s political elite must recognize that they are not exempt from the sacrifices being made by the people they represent. The Prime Minister must ensure that the pay raise is reasonable, transparent, and part of a broader fiscal strategy that prioritizes the needs of ordinary Pakistanis. Any increase should be modest and aligned with the country’s long-term economic recovery plan—rather than an immediate, self-serving pay increase for lawmakers. The public is watching, and this proposal must be handled with the utmost care and responsibility.