Editorial
In Pakistan, Articles 9 and 14 of the Constitution guarantee the right to life, liberty, dignity, and privacy for all citizens. However, these rights are not universally accessible, particularly for the transgender community, often referred to as Khwaja Sira. Despite the constitutional provisions intended to protect all citizens from discrimination, transgender individuals remain among the most marginalized and vulnerable groups in society. Their struggle for recognition and basic human rights continues amidst widespread ostracism and violence, particularly in conservative regions such as Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, where a staggering 479 attacks against transgender women were reported in 2018 alone, according to Human Rights Watch.
The societal norms dictating rigid gender roles and escalating intolerance create an environment where violence against transgender individuals often goes unchecked. Many attacks stem from personal vendettas, typically involving disgruntled former partners, or are perpetrated by families in a misguided attempt to “restore honor.” The 2022 shooting of five transgender individuals, resulting in one fatality, highlights the dangerous consequences of such societal pressures. The overall sense of helplessness is exacerbated by the community’s economic vulnerabilities, further isolating them from protection.
Pl, watch the video and subscribe to the YouTube channel of republicpolicy.com
In response to these challenges, the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act of 2018 aimed to provide legal recognition and safeguard against workplace harassment. Yet, despite the legislation, violence persists unabated; between 2019 and 2023, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa saw 267 reported cases of violence, with only one leading to a conviction. Factors contributing to this travesty include police inefficiency, victim intimidation, and pressure to withdraw complaints in favor of settlements, revealing a glaring failure of the justice system to protect the marginalized.
Moreover, the May 2023 ruling by the Federal Shariat Court undermined parts of the 2018 Act, especially the right to self-identification, momentarily halting the issuance of identity cards to transgender individuals. This precarious situation denies them access to essential services, reinforcing their societal alienation.
Given the ineffectiveness of existing policies, comprehensive reforms within the criminal justice system are critical. The state must adopt a proactive stance in supporting the transgender community, ensuring justice for victims of violence, and holding offenders accountable. Without decisive action, the cycle of violence and discrimination will perpetuate, further fracturing the societal fabric that binds us all.
